Sunday, December 9, 2007

Mangalore Special Economic Zone Opposed

MANGALORE, July 26, 2007: The Krishi Bhoomi Samrakshana Samithi which has been formed by the local farmers and residents has resolved not to give out their lands for development of the planned Mangalore Special Economic Zone(MSEZ).
Addressing a press conference here today the Samithi President M. Madhukar Amin told that the Samithi which has collected views from the land owners and farmers in the villages has found out that none of the farmer families were willing to give away their agricultural lands for the proposed MSEZ.
Mr. Amin said the MSEZ Managing Director had recently given statement in the media that only 5 percent of the identified land was cultivable land and rest were fallow lands and almost all farmer families had consented to give up their lands. This statement was not true he added.
Mr. Amin said the Samithi had been particularly annoyed about converting the agricultural lands into industrial area and displacing the farmers. He said the Samithi members had articulated not just anguish over losing their agricultural patches but also were feeling insecure about their future as they did not know anything else but farming for a living.
Karnataka Industrial Area Development Board (KIADB) plans to acquire 2035.31 acres of rich agricultural land in four villages in Mangalore taluk namely Permude, Tenka Yekkaru, Kutthethoor and Delanthabettu. All these villages have survived on agriculture so far and there were any fallow lands available in these villages and perhaps there are as less as 2-3 percent of fallow lands in this cluster of villages.
General Secretary of the Samithi Lawrance D'Cunha giving the extent of land that every village would lose, said that most of the lands were Patta and very little belonged to the government. In Permude there are 792.71 acres of land in patta category and only 82.00 acres in government name. In Kutthethoor 269.79 acres were patta and 74.63 government lands. In Delanthabettu 236.141acres patta and 132.339 acres government and in Thenka Yekkaru 446.68 acres of patta land and just 3.02 belonged to the government land category.
The Samithi has also expressed fears that the MSEZ project could be one large real estate scam in the making. The Samithi has taken the instance of the KIADB acquiring large chunk of land for the Mangalore Refineries and Petrochemicals and had quietly allotted 400 acres to BASF. The series of meetings which the Samithi held in the villages have expressed fears of more polluting industries to come in the SEZ and this has made their resolve to not to give their lands for MSEZ stronger Mr. D'Cunha said
If these lands were to be acquired various religious shrines including bootha sthaanas churches and temples and Naga banas will be lost for the community. People in these four villages are not taking it lightly and have expressed their strong resentment against taking over the lands. Some of the shrines that will be lost for the people include Somanatha Temple, Bhandara Mane, Taulava Math, Mukkodi Huli Chamundi shrine and St. John Baptist Church all at Permude. Kodamanithya bootha sthaanas in Thenka Yekkaru and Shibaroor. This shrine had religious connection with the Kateel Durga Parameshwari temple in Kateel Mr. D'Cunha stated.

Yekkaru village says no to SEZ

MANGALORE, July 29, 2007: The key Grama Panchayat among four others which have been earmarked by the government to give out their lands - Thenka Yekkaru has said a big `No' for any take over of their lands for building Special Economic Zone. This firm reply came during a special Grama Sabha convened by the Deputy Commissioner M. Maheshwara Rao on Saturday at Thenka Yekkaru village 30 kilometers from here.
Representatives of 3000 farmer families of Thenka Yekkaru village have told the Deputy Commisioner in no uncertain terms that they will not give their lands out for Mangalore Special Economic Zone. The Grama Panchayat president Sudhip Amin told the Deputy Commissioner that the Panchayat had passed a resolution on 20 July 2007 to the effect that the Panchayat will not give permission to any construction activities that is connected to the MSEZ or will it grant permission to convert agricultural land or acquire land belonging to the village for industrial purposes.
Farmers said acquiring over 4000 acres in four villages namely Delanthabettu, Yekkaru, Permude and Bajpe in the largest agricultural taluk of Mangalore the agricultural output will come down notably and could push the district into a serious food insecurity. The district will also suffer due to loss of production of fruits, flowers and vegetables to a great extent. All these shortages will hit the immediate market place at Mangalore.
The villagers also pointed out that there was no unemployment in Dakshina Kannada district and therefore there was no need for creating industrial employment. They said the people here are happily employed in their own farms and agricultural pastures and dairy farms and were earning their livelihood with their own strength.
Member of Mangalore Taluk Panchayat Suresh Shetty the MSEZ will end up as a largest disintegrating factor of the district. It was not justified for the government to take away the agri lands from the farmers and make them work in an industrial house as a labourer. It was nothing but pushing him to become a forced employee from a land lord and a farmer.
Lawrence D'Souza also a farmer said the village would give whole hearted support if the government had proposed to have Special Economic Zone for Agriculture in Mangalore instead the multi purpose MSEZ.
In his effort to convince the villagers Mr. Maheshwara Rao assured the villagers right compensation package which will include price for their land, houses, plantation, wells and also employment for children of the house and housing facility for one of the elderly person of the house. This package would totally work out to be nearly Rs. 20 lakhs per acre which is the highest in the country offered so far for any SEZ he added.

Permude: Villagers confront SEZ officials

Permude Village (Mangalore Taluk), October 30, 2007: The three villages Yekkaru, Permude and Delanthabettu which are supposed to give way to the Special Economic Zone in Mangalore taluk went tense today after there was a series of tussles between the officials of the Mangalore SEZ special purpose vehicle (SPV) and the villagers over the issue of survey for land to the proposed SEZ.

The on going protest about Survey and acquisition of land by the SEZ(Special Economic Zone) and KIADB (Karnataka Industrial Area Development Board) officials in proposed area at Permude near Bajpe, had nearly reached flash point between the villagers and the officials.
Villagers had planned to lock the Panchayat office today in protest of the Panchayat giving permission to the SPV to carry on the survey which was against the will of people. The villagers contend that the entire three villages had rich agricultural pastures. They argued that by giving permission to acquire, hundreds of villagers will be divested of their livelihood. They argued with the SPV officials that they will not be able to give their lands for the SEZ . The day was saved when the police arrived in time to prevent locking of the Panchayat office by the villagers.

The proposed land for Special Economic Zone stretches out to be 1800 acres in three villages in Mangalore taluk. The Karnataka Raitha Sangha as well as Krishi Boomi Samrakshana Samithi have taken this initiative.
When police tried to avoid protesters from locking of Panchayath, Hot discussion happened between them. At that time convener of Krishi Bhoomi Samrakshana samithi Vidya Dinakar who spoke to the police and asked not pressurize the villagers to stop their agitation. But the police were not in a mood to relent.
But when the tempers cooled down the Grama Panchayat president Sudhip Amin told the Deputy Commissioner that the Panchayat on 20 July 2007 in its extraordinary meeting had resolved that the Panchayat will not give permission to any construction activities related to the MSEZ or will it give permission to convert land or acquire land belonging to the village particularly the agricultural land.

One of the land lords Hemalatha said by acquiring over 4000 acres of land in the rich agricultural taluk the local food grain production will come down drastically and thousands of tonnes of fruits and vegetables will also be lost for not just for the people of village but also for the city of Mangalore. This will also put the food security of over 5 lakh people living in Mangalore into jeopardy she argued. She also did not agree that there was unemployment in the Dakshina Kannada district and said the villagers do not seek employment in SEZ but were contented with their agriculture and their business she added. Taluk Panchayat member Suresh Shetty said it was not justified for the government to take away the farmlands of the farmers and to make them work as an ordinary employee of some company of which he did not know anything. He said every farmer was self sufficient and also produced food for others. Lawrence D’Souza also a farmer said the village would give whole hearted support if the government wanted to have Special Economic Zone for Agriculture in Mangalore instead the multi purpose MSEZ.

Mangalore: Protests against MSEZ to be intensified

MANGALORE Oct 15: The Karnataka Rajya Raitha Sangha (KRRS) has plunged into the ongoing agitation against the acquisition of land under for the proposed Mangalore Special Economic Zone, thereby fortifying the efforts of Krishibhoomi Samrakshana Samiti (KSS), an organisation fighting on behalf of the farmers in the affected villages.
Kodihalli Chandrashekhar, president of KRRS, visited Permude, Delantha Bettu, Tenka Yekkaru and Kuthethoor, which have been notified for land acquisition, on Sunday on the invitation of the KSS. He spoke to farmers, assessed the situation and pledged full support to the agitation. He addressed a massive gathering of farmers and counselled them on the perils of giving up their land for the SEZ. The SEZ is expected to attract Rs. 100,000 crore worth of investments over the next few years.

Mangalore: Quarry workers join the agitation against MSEZ

MANGALORE Nov 19: The agitation against the proposed Mangalore Special Economic Zone which had developed into a farmers’ movement over the last few months, is set to change radically with granite quarry owners, workers and contractors joining it.
About four hundred workers and contractors of granite quarry have joined forces with Krishi Bhoomi Samrakshana Samiti (KBSS), an organisation led by Madhukar Amin, that has been representing agitating farmers in the region. The newcomers are being led by R. Kannan and Robert Menezez, both granite quarry owners in Thenka Yekkaru village.
The owners and occupants of 2,035 acres in Bala, Thokkur, Kalavaru, Bajpe, Permude, Thenka Yekkaru, Delanthabettu, and Kuthethur on the outskirts of Mangalore, have been notified for the MSEZ. The quarry workers and contractors belong to Thenka Yekkaru village and are employed in six granite quarries operating on five acres. According to Sudeep Amin, president of Thenka Yekkaru gram panchayat, about 120 workers from various parts of South India, have voters’ identity cards and many of them have been residing in the area for nearly two decades. Workers stand to lose more than livelihood.
Nagibai (31) from Davangere district has been working in the quarries at Thenka Yekkaru for 14 years now. She has two children, studying in a Government school — one is in sixth standard and the other in ninth. “After a lot of troubles, we have settled here. My contractor is very kind. My children are good at studies and the teachers are helpful. Why should our lives get disrupted all over again? I am not going to leave,” she says. A senior resettlement and rehabilitation officer with MSEZ Limited confesses that people will be given jobs. He said there was no 100 percent guarantee of jobs for every displaced person.
A.G. Pai, chief operating officer, MSEZ Limited, while confirming that there was no compensation package for people like Rajkumar, said: “These contractors can find work elsewhere”.However, the dissent is yet to percolate to the last worker in the quarries. Prakash (36) from Davangere, has been working in the quarry for the last 16 years. He is clueless about the SEZ and the ongoing agitation against it. He is unaware of the notification.

MSEZ: SHRC to take up farmers' cases

MANGALORE Nov 22, 2007: The Karnataka State Human Rights Commission will take up cases which involves harassment to the farmers and snatching away of their livelihood through promotion of Special Economic Zones in the state according to the Chairperson S. R. Nayak .
He addressed a press conference here today and stated that however the commission will not interfere in cases of land acquisition being necessary for the common good

Mr. Nayak said "Individual rights sometimes have to give way for social rights." The problems caused by land acquisition for SEZs is not something new in India, he said and admitted he did not have full knowledge of developments in this part of the country. Speaking on the issue of Mangalore - Bangalore road, he said that commission would not take up the issue as it is in high court.
However, the SHRC will also take suo moto cognizance of media reports which highlight gross violation of individuals rights, he said. The Commission, which came into existence on July 25, is yet to get the required staff and office space. The recent political developments in the state have cast their shadow on the effective functioning of the Commission.
Referring to the raids carried out by the Commission on police stations in Bangalore, namely those at Chandra Layout, Ulsoor and Koramangala based on complaints of people being kept in illegal detention there, Mr. Nayak said this action has had a salutary effect. The police higher-ups have taken note of our concerns in this regard and the commission has not received any complaints in this regard ever since this action, he noted.